My grandma used to make Bread and Butter Pickles. They were my favorite over dill pickles. I recall an open jar of bread and butter pickles on many a Sunday dinner table. I usually ate a few with whatever what served that day. We did not need to be eating sandwiches to eat bread and butter pickles. We ate them for the flavor.
Memories
I reached out to my aunts to find out if they had a recipe passed down by my grandma to them. A few hours later, I had a picture of a hand written recipe card text to me from an aunt.
A warm feeling flooded my heart remembering my grandma as I looked at the familiar handwriting which had filled letters, cards and notes sent or given to me over the 34 years I was blessed to have this particular grandma in my life.
Bread and butter pickles, tasting like hers were not easy to find. Now, given the opportunity to create my own, I could hardly sleep. my excitement building. The 2 Tokyo Green variety plants produced 50 plus cucumbers in a week. I had plenty to work with, eat and share with family.
In years gone by, pickles were soaked, prior to canning, in either alum or lime to promote a crisper pickle. For myself, I choose my health over a crisp pickle and opted to leave out the soaking process.
Her recipe written for a batch of 6 lbs. of cucumbers required a bit of math on my part. Instead of combining all of the spice and seeds, I would be placing a specific amount in each jar similar to the way I prepared the Dill Pickles.
Here is my version of my grandma’s Bread and Butter Pickle Recipe. Spoiler alert: Yes, they do taste like my grandma’s, despite skipping the unhealthy step of soaking in alum and adding less sugar. And no, I did not open a jar I canned. Keep reading to learn more.
NOTE: This page or post contains affiliate links. When you click and make a purchase I earn a portion of the money you spend at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Thank you for your support.
Ingredients
- 2 T Tumeric
- Large Onion Chopped
- 2 T Celery Seed
- 2 & 1/2 T Mustard Seed
- 7 lbs. Cucumbers
- 3 cups Apple Cider Vinegar
- 3 cups Water
- Redmond Sea Salt
- 2 – 4.5 cups of Sugar (amount is optional)
Tools
- Water Bath Canner
- 7-pint jars
- Lids
- Rings
- Pot
- Jar lifter
- Plastic Spoon
- Towels
The Preparation
I sterilized the jars by boiling 10 min in the water bath canner prior to filling the jars.
Filling a pot with 3 cups water, 3 cups apple cider vinegar and 2 ¼ cups Evaporated Cane power as a sugar substitute, I started these heating on the stove while I filled the jars.
Preparing Jars
Add 1/3 T of Turmeric
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2ff49/2ff49398d88fe1a398f975b6062df3e26d262a24" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/01088/010883ea7d71738b82729fb4c72d30b0dd398e12" alt=""
Next, 1/2 T of Celery Seed
The third ingredient to go into the jar is 1/2 T of Mustard Seed
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ebd92/ebd926477f704470a05af3ecc9fd4c53a8b8156c" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f47e8/f47e84cc064ba8ab0d5ba164749fe0f8659f36ad" alt=""
I grabbed a handful of chopped onions and placed into the jar. Since a handful is subjective a better description would be just enough to cover the bottom of the jar.
I measured between a 1/2 and 1/3 T of Redmond Sea Salt. This salt has a flavor all its own. It has not been processed like many other sea salt options on the market.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ae288/ae288c086950712fd43cea08669f68fd41dd0d5e" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/432e5/432e5377ae3dd354dc00e388ef4b747ecc084db7" alt=""
My last step before adding the brine to the jars was to slice the cucumbers and stuff as many as I could into each jar. I strived to keep the level of cucumbers below the threads of the jar.
By the time I had the jars ready the brine was boiling on the stove. It had reached a boil before I was ready for it so I turned it way down. Also, I stirred it a couple times until I knew the sugar had dissolved.
I filled the jars to a ½ inch below the top of the jar or just below the threads.
After using the plastic spoon to push any air bubbles to the top and squashing most of them, I cleaned the rims. I placed lids on the jars and rings.
Processing in Water Bath
Off I went to the water bath canner a few jars at a time. When the water reached a heavy rolling boil, I noted the time. After 10 min, had past, I removed the processed jars setting them on a towel.
I love hearing the pop of sealing canned goods. And yes, again I covered the jars with a towel too. If you did not read my post on How to Can Dill Pickles, you might not know I picked up this habit from canning with my grandma as a child.
I will say the workflow is a bit different because of heating the brine, but still an easy process, this thing of canning bread and butter pickles.
I mean it simply isn’t on the same level of needing to dodge a stallion about to plow me over or standing my ground when a wild mustang stallion charged my direction with his ears pinned. Ah, the quiet life I lead these days.
Completed
I canned a total of 15 pints and 2 quarts. The quart jars I processed for an extra 5 minutes, a total of 15 minutes.
Since I had extra brine left over and hated to waste it, I put it in a glass jar with all the other ingredients except chopped onion as I was out. Covering the jar with a lid and rim I placed in the refrigerator. I sampled the next morning, evening and morning of day 2. The flavor continues to improve. These ingredients seem to work for refrigerator pickles too.
Tips
- Wash Cucumbers and remove both ends before slicing. I keep a pan of water close as I slice.
- Have the water in Canning pot hot and close to boiling as possible before placing the fill jars into process. It is important to fill hot jars and add a hot brine so the jars are not cold going into the almost boiling water. The glass may break if you place a cold glass jar in boiling hot water.